Skip to content

Zero-Proof Hot Buttered “Rum” Recipe

Zero-Proof Hot Buttered “Rum” Recipe - zero-proof-shop
For this hot buttered “rum” recipe, rum is replaced with a touch of rum extract so the beverages still feature the signature flavor of the spirit without the alcohol content.

It isn't the holidays without hot buttered rum! The buttery spice fueled drink is so delicious and comforting. Warmth greets you with every sip followed by an array of spices including cinnamon, nutmeg and cardamom working harmoniously to create a delicious flavor profile, the sweetness comes in soon after, and then the salty touch from the butter combined with the dark brown sugar used creates an incredible sweet-salty balance. For this hot buttered "rum" recipe, rum is replaced with a touch of rum extract so the beverages still feature the signature flavor of the spirit without the alcohol content and the use of cardamom gives the drinks a complexity that is very complementary to the other spicy additions. Whip up a batch and cozy up with your family in front of the fireplace or welcome holiday party guests with a tray of these winter classics. 

 

Total Time:  15 minutes

Active Time: 10 minutes

Hot Buttered "Rum" Recipe Ingredients

Serves 8

  • 2 cups water

  • ½ cup salted butter, softened

  • 1 ½ cups dark brown sugar

  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

  • ¼ teaspoon ground nutmeg

  • 1/8 teaspoon ground cardamom

  • Pinch of ground cloves

  • 1 teaspoon rum extract

  • 1 cup heavy cream

     

Hot Buttered "Rum" Recipe Directions
  1. Bring the water to a boil in a medium saucepan.

  2. Meanwhile, add the butter to a mixing bowl with the sugar, spices and rum extract.

  3. Beat until smooth and well combined.

  4. Add the butter, sugar and spice mixture to the pot of water along with the heavy cream.

  5. Reduce to a simmer, cover and let simmer for 5 minutes.

  6. Pour into glasses and serve.

Read more

Back to all
Our Favorite Non-Alcoholic Gins Alternatives (updated 2021) - zero-proof-shop
Top Non-Alcoholic Gins, As Told by The Zero Proof

A roundup of our favorite non-alcoholic gins—for seekers of the botanical, crisp, zesty spirit in its zero proof form.

Link to Top Non-Alcoholic Gins, As Told by The Zero Proof
Negroni - zero-proof-shop

Recipes

Non-Alcoholic Negroni Recipe

The perfect non-alcoholic Negroni. Accept no substitutes.

Link to Non-Alcoholic Negroni Recipe
Virgin Manhattan - zero-proof-shop

Recipes

Non-Alcoholic Manhattan Recipe

A classic non-alcoholic take on Manhattan.

Link to Non-Alcoholic Manhattan Recipe
Finder's Old-Fashioned - zero-proof-shop
Finder's Non-Alcoholic Old-Fashioned

A bitter riff on the traditional whiskey cocktail, this one with The Pathfinder is for those who want something a little darker—and non-alcoholic.

Link to Finder's Non-Alcoholic Old-Fashioned
Zero-Proof Pimm's Cup Mocktail - zero-proof-shop
Non-Alcoholic Pimm's Cup Recipe

Using balsamic vinegar instead of booze to create a refreshing non-alcoholic Pimm's Cup cocktail.

Link to Non-Alcoholic Pimm's Cup Recipe
Virgin Old Fashioned - zero-proof-shop
Non-Alcoholic Old Fashioned Recipes

A classic non-alcoholic Old Fashioned recipe, with a few backup options if you're running low on time.

Link to Non-Alcoholic Old Fashioned Recipes
Non-Alcoholic Mojito Mocktail - zero-proof-shop
Non-Alcoholic Mojito Recipe

A clean, refreshing non-alcoholic mojito recipe.

Link to Non-Alcoholic Mojito Recipe
Café du Monde Martini - zero-proof-shop

Recipes

Café du Monde Non-Alcoholic Martini

With espresso martinis all the rage, we wanted to look to other regional coffees for inspiration. This bittersweet non-alcoholic drink is named after the 24 hour café in New Orleans famous for serving piping hot beignets buried under drifts of powdered sugar alongside distinctively bitter chicory coffee.

Link to Café du Monde Non-Alcoholic Martini
Non-Alcoholic Mexican Hot Chocolate Recipe
Non-Alcoholic Mexican Hot Chocolate Recipe

This spicy, cinnamon infused hot chocolate with non-alcoholic tequila will warm you from the inside out... and it's surprisingly easy to make.   

Link to Non-Alcoholic Mexican Hot Chocolate Recipe
Image of an espresso martini with a very thick head of foam
The Perfect Non-Alcoholic Espresso Martini Recipe

There are a lot of recipes for non-alcoholic espresso martinis out there, but they almost always lack the thick head of foam that makes their alcoholic cousins so photogenic. Not anymore. 

Link to The Perfect Non-Alcoholic Espresso Martini Recipe
Kristin Chaconas’s Electric Relaxation (Non-alcoholic Boulevardier) - zero-proof-shop
Kristin Chaconas’s Electric Relaxation (Non-alcoholic Boulevardier)

Kristin’s tribute to A Tribe Called Quest, Electric Relaxation is a delicious, non-alcoholic Boulevardier. The Boulevardier is a Negroni variation that substitutes bourbon for gin. Still bitter and bracing, but with a smoky roundness that eases you into cooler weather.

Link to Kristin Chaconas’s Electric Relaxation (Non-alcoholic Boulevardier)
French 75 - zero-proof-shop
Non-Alcoholic French 75 Recipe

The cocktail of choice in the movie Casablanca, the flirtatious French 75 looks glamorous but is easy to make. The original was named after a field gun used by the French army in World War I, as it was so strong you'd feel like you'd been shelled the night before. This non-alcoholic version packs all the flavor punch but won't leave you with a concussive headache. 

Link to Non-Alcoholic French 75 Recipe
Kellie Thorn’s Gnista Coffee Old-Fashioned - zero-proof-shop
Kellie Thorn’s Gnista Coffee Old-Fashioned

A more grown up option for when you've outgrown the espresso martini but still love coffee cocktails. Rich, sophisticated, and still guaranteed to give you a bit of a caffeine kick.

Link to Kellie Thorn’s Gnista Coffee Old-Fashioned
Miguel de Leon’s Zen Zero
Miguel de Leon’s Zen Zero

Think lychee martini meets aperitivo spritz. 

Link to Miguel de Leon’s Zen Zero
Gnista Cocktails: The Perfect Non-Alcoholic Drinks to Transition from Summer to Fall - zero-proof-shop
Gnista Cocktails: The Perfect Non-Alcoholic Drinks to Transition from Summer to Fall

Ease out of summer and into fall with recipes from some of our favorite mixologists, showcasing the flavors of Swedish botanicals.

Link to Gnista Cocktails: The Perfect Non-Alcoholic Drinks to Transition from Summer to Fall
SpottieOttieDopaliscious from Redbird Atlanta - zero-proof-shop
SpottieOttieDopaliscious from Redbird Atlanta

Developed by Kristin Chaconas at Redbird in Atlanta, the SpottieOttieDopaliscious is a delicious, booze-free riff on the Pearl Diver. (And, yes, it is named for the song by hometown heroes, Outkast.)

Link to SpottieOttieDopaliscious from Redbird Atlanta
Pineapple Garden Sparkler - zero-proof-shop

Recipes

Pineapple Garden Sparkler

This zero-proof blend of ISH Mexican Agave Spirit, Optimist Botanicals Fresh, and a simple shrub made with fresh pineapple, this drink is a tropical garden in a glass.

Link to Pineapple Garden Sparkler
40ISHº North Margarita - zero-proof-shop
40ISHº North Margarita

A distinctly northern twist on the berry margarita, using ISH Mexican Agave Spirit and flavors found 40º or more above the equator (hence the name).

Link to 40ISHº North Margarita
Halcyon Sunset - zero-proof-shop
Halcyon Sunset

A simple honey syrup infused with chamomile tea adds a complex but comforting sweetness to ISH Mexican Agave Spirit and punchy ruby red grapefruit.

Link to Halcyon Sunset
{"statementLink":"","footerHtml":"","hideMobile":false,"hideTrigger":false,"disableBgProcess":false,"language":"en","position":"left","leadColor":"#146ff8","triggerColor":"#146ff8","triggerRadius":"50%","triggerPositionX":"left","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerIcon":"wheels","triggerSize":"small","triggerOffsetX":45,"triggerOffsetY":90,"mobile":{"triggerSize":"small","triggerPositionX":"left","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerOffsetX":40,"triggerOffsetY":85,"triggerRadius":"50%"}}
true